BigBrotherAwards 2007

Wolfgang Schäuble was not given an award in 2007. After all, he is not single-handedly responsible for the “Stasi 2.0”, and his profile should not be raised even further by an award. Among those that did receive awards were Deutsche Bahn (German Railways), two ministers in the Federal Government and the Federal Prosecutor (Generalbundesanwältin),

News

  • The latest BigBrotherAwards gala was held on 5 May 2017.
  • All award speeches have been published on the German and English “awardees” pages.

Awardees 2007

Business: Deutsche Bahn

The BigBrotherAward 2007 in the “Business” category goes to Deutsche Bahn AG (German Railways PLC), represented by its CEO, Hartmut Mehdorn, for their systematic endeavours to make anonymous travelling practically impossible: abandoning ticket counters, ticket machines not accepting cash, personalised ticket selling on the internet, birth date and photo as mandatory items for buying the discount pass (BahnCard), ubiquitous video surveillance, an RFID chip in the all-inclusive one-year ticket (BahnCard 100) without customers being informed, and much more.

Consumer Protection: Hotel chains

The BigBrotherAward 2007 in the “Consumer Protection” category goes to the international hotel chains in Germany, Marriott, Hyatt and Intercontinental (representing many others), for their collection and centralised storing of critical personal information of customers without their knowledge. This includes drinking and eating habits, use of pay TV, allergies, all private and professional addresses, credit card data, complaints, all kinds of preferences – everything is kept.

Technology: PTV

The BigBrotherAward 2007 in the “Technology” category goes to PTV Planung Transport Verkehr AG, represented by Dr Hans Hubschneider, for their system for individual rating of car insurances with the so-called “pay-as-you-drive” technology, i.e. a device that records routes and driving behaviour in a car and transmits these data to the insurance company.

Politics: Peer Steinbrück

The BigBrotherAward in the “Politics” category goes to the Federal Minister of Finance, Mr Peer Steinbrück, for introducing a life-long Tax ID number for all taxable persons, which bears an eerie resemblance to the unconstitutional concept of a personal code number.

Communication: Brigitte Zypries

The BigBrotherAward in the “Communication” category goes to the Federal Minister of Justice, Ms Brigitte Zypries, for a bill that will introduce the retention of all telecommunications connection data in Germany. With this bill, the Minister is deliberately ignoring jurisdiction by the Federal Constitutional Court, which had ruled in 1983 in its census verdict that the collection of non-anonymised data for undetermined or not-yet-determined purposes is unconstitutional.

Government Authorities & Administration: Monika Harms

The BigBrotherAward in the “Government and Administration” category goes to Germany’s Federal Prosecutor (Generalbundesanwältin), Monika Harms. She receives the BigBrotherAward for her anti-terror measures against opponents of the G8 summit in May this year, particularly for systematic postal surveillance in Hamburg and for her instructions to collect and preserve body scent samples from G8 opponents suspected of militancy.

Trends

The BigBrotherAwards highlight individual cases – but often it is easy to see common phenomena or themes. The jury has been asking itself which themes are “on the rise” currently. Here is one where we fear exactly that to be happening.

Notes of Disapproval

With more than 500 nominations, the BigBrotherAwards jury has had to manage a record workload this year – a kind of data mining for data protection and civic rights. It is therefore all the more important to point out that “below” the laureates, there are many cases of illegal activities, data greed, but also sheer impudence and carelessness. To make sure that they don’t go completely scot-free, we briefly introduce some of the “unlucky losers” that didn’t quite make it to the “podium of shame”.

About BigBrotherAwards

The BigBrotherAwards highlight privacy and data protection offenders in business and politics, they have consequently been called “Oscars for data leeches” by the French paper Le Monde. BigBrotherAwards are an international project. 19 countries have so far given these awards for dubious practices.

The German awards are organised and held by  Digitalcourage. Among the co-organisers are the German Association for Data Protection (Deutsche Vereinigung für Datenschutz, DVD), International League for Human Rights and the Chaos Computer Club.